Middle School Assignments - No We're Not Talking Homework Here!

Bill Garrett in cooperation with Marylu Tyndell (bgarrett@dimacs.rutgers.edu),(bgarrett@fast.net)
(tyndell@dimacs.rutgers.edu)


General Information

The Problem

Our school district has three middle schools. We will explore which school students in our district are assigned to attend compared to their nearest school (based first on "as the crow flies" and then using a realistic unit circle based on predominant street layout within the district.) Then we will examine whether the plan our district uses to assign students seems reasonable based on racial demographics and relative sizes of schools.

Suggested Materials
map of the school district with school locations

tools to determine perpendicular bisectors (ruler and protractor or compass and straightedge, or tracing paper)

transparent grid for drawing "unit squares"

population demographics charts

school data (cuffent and possible enrollments, current attendance areas)
Prerequisites
significance of perpendicular bisectors and a method to determine them

concept of a unit circle and "unit square"

Activity Description

Guided Exploration

Students will work in groups of three. They will create the Voronoi diagram for the three middle schools based on line-of-sight distances. Then they will create the Voronoi diagram based on the "unit square" since most of our streets within the distance are relatively perpendicular north-south and east-west streets. They will be asked to compare and contrast the two diagrams.

Students will then be asked to compare the geographically efficient attendance boundaries they generated to the actual attendance boundaries. They will be expected to consider relative school sizes and racial balance in determining if the current attendance boundaries are reasonable relative to the district's goals.



Concluding the Exploration

I expect this exercise to take two or three days depending on how much information I can obtain about the demographics of the school district. The first day will be used to create the Voronoi diagrams. The intent of doing both diagrams is to (a) create a successful product quickly with the line-of-sight diagram, (b) look at the situation in a more completely realistic manner with the "unit square" diagram, and (c) compare the diagrams to see if there is significant enough differences to require using the more intensive diagrams for further studies regarding our elementary schools.

The second and possibly third days will be used to look at the attendance boundaries in existence compared to the boundaries that we determine from our diagrams and consider the differences in regard to demographics and school size. We will use charts of some form (not yet determined) to summarize our results. Depending on the results we will ask from central administration for rationale regarding why students are assigned as thev are.



Sample Results from Exploration

Pending consumation of the activity



Writing Assignment

Included in activity



Followup Problems or Activities

See last line of "Concluding the Exploration"

Teaching Notes

References