New Jersey Mathematics Curriculum Framework - Preliminary Version (January 1995)
© Copyright 1995 New Jersey Mathematics Coalition

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

Meaning and Importance

The wide availability of computing and calculating technology has given us the opportunity to significantly reconceive the role of computation and numerical operations in our school mathematics programs. Up until this point in our history, the mathematics program has called for the expenditure of tremendous amounts of time in helping children to develop proficiency with pencil-and-paper computational procedures. Most people defined proficiency as a combination of speed and accuracy with the standard algorithms. Now, though, the societal reality is that adults who need to perform calculations quickly and accurately have electronic tools that are both more accurate and more efficient than any human being. It is time to re-examine the reasons to teach pencil-and-paper computational algorithms to children and to revise the curriculum in light of that re-examination.

K-12 Development and Emphases

At the same time that technology has made the traditional focus on paper-and-pencil skills less important, it has also presented us with a situation where some numerical operations, skills, and concepts are much more important than they have ever been. Estimation skills, for example, are critically important if one is to be a competent user of calculating technology. People must know the range in which the answer to a given problem should lie before doing any calculation, they must be able to assess the reasonableness of the results of a string of computations, they should be able to work quickly and easily with changes in order of magnitude, and they should be able to be satisfied with the results of an estimation when an exact answer is unnecessary. Mental mathematics skills, too, play a more important role in a highly technological world. Simple two-digit computations or operations that involve powers of ten should be performed mentally by a mathematically literate adult. Students should have enough confidence in their ability with these types of computations to do them mentally rather than looking for either a calculator or pencil and paper. And, probably of greatest importance, a students knowledge of the meanings and uses of the various arithmetic operations is still an essential concern. Even with the best of computing devices, it is still the human who must decide which operations need to be done and in what order to answer the question at hand. The construction of solutions to lifes everyday problems, and to societys larger ones, will require students to be thoroughly familiar with the mathematical operations and processes that are available.

The major shift in this area of the curriculum, then, is one away from drill and practice of pencil-and-paper procedures and toward real-world applications of operations, wise choices of appropriate computational strategies, and integration of the numerical operations with other components of the mathematics curriculum. So what is the role of pencil-and-paper computation in a mathematics program for the year 2000? Should children be able to perform any calculations by hand? Are those procedures worth any time in the school day? Of course they should and of course they are.

Most simple pencil-and-paper procedures should still be taught and one-digit basic facts should still be committed to memory. We want students to be proficient with two- and three-digit addition and subtraction and with multiplication and division involving two-digit factors or divisors. But there should be changes both in the way we teach those processes and in where we go from there. The focus on the learning of those procedures should be on understanding the procedures themselves and on the development of accuracy. There is no longer any need to concentrate on the development of speed. To serve the needs of understanding and accuracy, non-traditional pencil-and-paper algorithms, or algorithms devised by the children themselves, may well be better choices than the standard algorithms, which were built mostly for speed. The excessive use of drill, necessary in the past to develop reflexive automaticity, is no longer necessary and should play a much smaller role in todays curriculum.

For procedures involving even larger numbers, or numbers with a greater number of digits, the intent ought to be to bring students to the point where they understand a pencil-and-paper procedure well enough to be able to extend it to as many places as needed, but certainly not to develop an old-fashioned kind of proficiency with such problems. In almost every instance where the student is confronted with such numbers in school, technology should be available to aid in the computation, and students should understand how to use it effectively. Calculators are the tools that real people in the real world use when they have to deal with similar situations and they should not be withheld from students in an effort to further an unreasonable and antiquated educational goal.

In summary, numerical operations continue to be a critical piece of the school mathematics curriculum and, indeed, a very important part of mathematics. But, there is perhaps a greater need for us to rethink our approach here than to do so for any other component. An enlightened mathematics program for todays children will empower them to use all of todays tools rather than require them to meet yesterdays expectations.


This overview duplicates the section of Chapter 8 that discusses this content standard. Although each content standard is discussed in a separate chapter, it is not the intention that each be treated separately in the classroom. Indeed, as noted in Chapter 1, an effective curriculum is one that successfully integrates these areas to present students with rich and meaningful cross-strand experiences. Many of the activities provided in this chapter are intended to convey this message; you may well be using other activities which would be appropriate for this document. Please submit your suggestions of additional integrative activities for inclusion in subsequent versions of this curriculum framework; address them to Framework, P.O.Box 10867, New Brunswick, NJ 08906.


STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

K-2 Overview

The wide availability of computing and calculating technology has given us the opportunity to significantly reconceive the role of computation and numerical operations in our elementary mathematics programs, but, in kindergarten through second grade, the effects will not be as evident as they will be in all of the other grade ranges. This is because the numerical operations content taught in these grades is so basic, so fundamental, and so critical to further progress in mathematics that much of it will remain the same. The approach to teaching that content, however, must still be changed to help achieve the goals expressed in The New Jersey Mathematics Standards.

Learning the meanings of addition and subtraction, gaining facility with basic facts, and mastering some computational procedures for multi-digit addition and subtraction are still the topics on which most of the instructional time in this area will be spent. There will be an increased conceptual and developmental focus to these aspects of the curriculum, though, away from a traditional drill-and-practice rote memory approach.

By the time they enter school, most young children can use counters to act out a mathematical story problem involving addition or subtraction and find a solution which makes sense. Their experiences in school need to build upon that ability and deepen the childrens understanding of the meanings of the operations. They also need to strengthen the childrens sense that modeling such situations as a way to understand them is the right thing to do. It is important that the variety of situations to which they are exposed include the full gamut of addition and subtraction. There are several slightly different taxonomies of the types of addition and subtraction, but one describes change problems, part-part-whole problems, equalize problems, and compare problems. Students need to recognize and model each for each operation.

Basic facts in addition and subtraction also continue to be very important. Students should be able to quickly and easily recall one-digit sums and differences. The most effective approach to enabling them to acquire this ability has been shown to be the focused and explicit use of basic fact strategies - conceptual techniques that make use of the childs understanding of number parts and relationships to help recover the appropriate sum or difference. By the end of second grade, students should not only be able to use counting on and back, make ten, and doubles and near doubles strategies, but also explain why they work by modeling them with counters.

Students must still be able to perform multi-digit addition and subtraction with pencil and paper, but the widespread availability of calculators has made the particular procedure used to perform the calculations less important. It need no longer be the single fastest, most efficient algorithm chosen without respect to the degree to which children understand it. Rather, the teaching of multi-digit computation should take on more of a problem solving approach, a more conceptual, developmental approach. Students should first use the models of multi-digit number that they are most comfortable with (base ten blocks, popsicle sticks, bean sticks) to explore the new class of problems. Students who have never formally done two-digit addition might be asked to use their materials to help figure out how many second graders there are in all in the two second grade classes in the school. Other, similar, real-world problems follow, some involving regrouping and others not.

After initial exploration, students share with each other all of the strategies theyve developed, the best ways theyve found for working with the tens and ones in the problem, and their own approaches (and names!) for regrouping. Most students can, with direction, take the results of those discussions and create their own pencil-and-paper procedures for addition and subtraction. The discussions can, of course, include the traditional approaches but these ought not to be seen as the only right way to do these operations.

Kindergarten through second grade teachers are also responsible for setting up an atmosphere where estimation and mental math are seen as reasonable ways to do mathematics. Of course students at these grade levels do almost exclusively mental math until they reach multi-digit operations, but estimation should also comprise a good part of the activity. Students involved in a good deal of real-world problem solving should begin to develop a sense of when estimation is appropriate and when an exact answer is necessary.

Technology should also be an important part of the environment in primary classrooms. Calculators provide a valuable teaching tool when used to do student-programmed skip counting, to offer estimation and mental math practice with target games, and to explore operations and number types that the students have not formally encountered yet. They should also be used routinely to perform computation in problem solving situations that the students may not be able to perform otherwise. This use prevents the need to artificially contrive real-world problems so that the numbers come out friendly.

The topics that should comprise the numerical operations focus of the kindergarten through second grade mathematics program are:

addition and subtraction basic facts
mutli-digit addition and subtraction

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

K-2 Expectations and Activities

The expectations for these grade levels appear below in boldface type. Each expectation is followed by activities which illustrate how the expectation can be addressed in the classroom.

Experiences will be such that all students in grades K-2:

A. develop meaning for the four basic operations by modeling and discussing a variety of problems.

B. develop proficiency with basic facts through the use of a variety of strategies.
C. construct, use, and explain procedures for performing whole number calculations in the various methods of computation.
D. use models to explore operations with fractions and decimals.
E. select and use an appropriate method for computing from among mental math, estimation, paper-and-pencil, and calculator methods and check the reasonableness of results.
F. use a variety of mental computation and estimation techniques.
G. understand and use relationships among operations and properties of operations.

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

3-4 Overview

The wide availability of computing and calculating technology has given us the opportunity to reconceive the role of computation and numerical operations in our third and fourth grade mathematics programs. Traditionally, tremendous amounts of time were spent at these levels helping children to develop proficiency and accuracy with pencil-and-paper procedures. Now, the societal reality is that adults needing to perform calculations quickly and accurately have electronic tools that are both more accurate and more efficient than those procedures. At the same time, though, the new technology has presented us with a situation where some numerical operations, skills, and concepts are much more important than they used to be. Estimation, mental computation, and understanding the meanings of the standard arithmetic operations all play a more significant role than ever in the everyday life of a mathematically literate adult.

The major shift in the curriculum that will take place in this realm, therefore, is one away from drill and practice of pencil-and-paper symbolic procedures and toward real-world applications of operations, wise choices of appropriate computational strategies, and integration of the numerical operations with other components of the mathematics curriculum.

Third and fourth graders are primarily concerned with cementing their understandings of addition and subtraction and developing new meanings for multiplication and division. They should be in an environment where they can do so by modeling and otherwise representing a whole variety of real-world situations in which these operations are appropriately used. It is important that the variety of situations to which they are exposed include the full gamut of multiplication and division. There are several slightly different taxonomies of these types of problems, but minimally students at this level should be exposed to repeated addition and subtraction, array, area, and expansion problems. Students need to recognize and model each for each operation.

Basic facts in multiplication and division also continue to be very important. Students should be able to quickly and easily recall one-digit products and quotients. The most effective approach to enabling them to acquire this ability has been shown to be the focused and explicit use of basic fact strategies - conceptual techniques that make use of the childs understanding of the operations and number relationships to help recover the appropriate product or quotient. Doubles and Doubles and One More are useful strategies, but also useful are discussions and understandings regarding the regularity in the nines facts, the roles of one and zero in these operations, and the roles of commutativity and distributivity.

Students must still be able to perform two-digit multiplication and division with pencil and paper, but the widespread availability of calculators has made the particular procedure used to perform the calculations less important. It need no longer be the single fastest, most efficient algorithm chosen without respect to the degree to which children understand it. Rather, the teaching of this two-digit computation should take on more of a problem solving approach, a more conceptual, developmental approach. Students should first use the models of multi-digit number that they are most comfortable with (base ten blocks, money) to explore the new class of problems. Students who have never formally done two-digit multiplication might be asked to use their materials to help figure out how many pencils are packed in the case just received in the school office. There are 24 boxes with a dozen pencils in each box. Are there enough for every student in the school to have one? Other, similar, real-world problems would follow, some involving regrouping and others not.

After initial exploration, students share with each other all of the strategies theyve developed, the best ways theyve found for working with the tens and ones in the problem, and their own approaches to dealing with the place value issues involved. Most students can, with direction, take the results of those discussions and create their own pencil-and-paper procedures for multiplication and division. The discussions can, of course, include the traditional approaches but these ought not to be seen as the only right way to do these operations.

Estimation and mental math also become critically important in these grade levels as students are inclined to use calculators for more and more of their work. In order to use that technology effectively, third and fourth graders must be able to use estimation to know the range in which the answer to a given problem should lie before doing any calculation, to assess the reasonableness of the results of a computation, and to be satisfied with the results of an estimation when an exact answer is unnecessary. Mental mathematics skills, too, play a more important role in third and fourth grade. Simple two-digit addition and subtraction problems and those involving powers of ten should be performed mentally. Students should have enough confidence in their ability with these types of computations to do them mentally rather than looking for either a calculator or pencil and paper.

Technology should also be an important part of the environment in third and fourth grade classrooms. Calculators provide a valuable teaching tool when used to do student-programmed repeated addition or subtraction, to offer estimation and mental math practice with target games, and to explore operations and number types that the students have not formally encountered yet. They should also be used routinely to perform computation in problem solving situations that the students may not be able to perform otherwise. This use prevents the need to artificially contrive real-world problems so that the numbers come out friendly.

The topics that should comprise the numerical operations focus of the third and fourth grade mathematics program are:

multiplication and division basic facts
multi-digit whole number addition and subtraction
two-digit whole number multiplication and division
decimal addition and subtraction
explorations with fraction operations

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

3-4 Expectations and Activities

The expectations for these grade levels appear below in boldface type. Each expectation is followed by activities which illustrate how the expectation can be addressed in the classroom.

Building upon K-2 expectations, experiences in grades 3-4 will be such that all students:

A. develop meaning for the four basic operations by modeling and discussing a variety of problems.

B. develop proficiency with basic facts through the use of a variety of strategies.
C. construct, use, and explain procedures for performing whole number calculations in the various methods of computation.
D. use models to explore operations with fractions and decimals.
E. select and use an appropriate method for computing from among mental math, estimation, paper-and-pencil, and calculator methods and check the reasonableness of results.
F. use a variety of mental computation and estimation techniques.
G. understand and use relationships among operations and properties of operations.

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

5-6 Overview

The wide availability of computing and calculating technology has given us the opportunity to significantly reconceive the role of computation and numerical operations in our fifth and sixth grade mathematics programs. Traditionally, tremendous amounts of time were spent helping children to develop proficiency and accuracy with pencil-and-paper procedures. Now, the societal reality is that adults needing to perform calculations quickly and accurately have electronic tools that are both more accurate and more efficient than those procedures. At the same time, though, the new technology has presented us with a situation where some numerical operations, skills, and concepts are much more important than they used to be. Estimation, mental computation, and understanding the meanings of the standard arithmetic operations all play a more significant role than ever in the everyday life of a mathematically literate adult.

The major shift in the curriculum that will take place at these grade levels, therefore, is one away from drill and practice of pencil-and-paper symbolic procedures and toward real-world applications of operations, wise choices of appropriate computational strategies, and integration of the numerical operations with other components of the mathematics curriculum.

Much research in the past decade has looked at students' understanding of operations with large whole numbers and with decimals and fractions. A valuable summary of the findings is presented in Number Concepts and Operations in the Middle Grades, published by Lawrence Erlbaum and Associates and available from NCTM. Part of the preface describes what has been the focus of the research:

In the primary grades, children experience number as whole numbers and operate on them by adding and subtracting. ..... Despite the fact that the unit throughout this period is a single whole entity (the whole number "1," a rather simple looking concept), acquiring a mature conceptualization of unit is a protracted and cognitively demanding process.

In the middle grades, the operations change from addition and subtraction to multiplication and division. And the numbers change, from whole numbers to rational numbers. Underneath all of the surface level changes is a fundamental change with far-reaching ramifications: a change in the nature of the unit.

Both multiplication and division demand different understandings of whole numbers than those necessary for addition and subtraction. And, obviously, working with fractions and decimals requires a restructuring of a child's notion of unit. The topics that should comprise the numerical operations focus of the fifth and sixth grade mathematics program, and thus raise all of these challenges for students, are:

multi-digit whole number multiplication and division
decimal multiplication and division
fraction operations
integer operations

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

5-6 Expectations and Activities

The expectations for these grade levels appear below in boldface type. Each expectation is followed by activities which illustrate how the expectation can be addressed in the classroom.

Building upon K-4 expectations, experiences in grades 5-6 will be such that all students:

H. select and use an appropriate method for computing from among mental math, estimation, pencil-and-paper, and calculator methods and check the reasonableness of results.

I. extend their understanding and use of arithmetic operations to fractions, decimals, integers, and rational numbers.
J. extend their basic understanding of basic arithmetic operations on whole numbers to include powers and roots.
K. develop, analyze, apply, and explain procedures for computation and estimation with whole numbers, fractions, decimals, integers, and rational numbers.
L. develop, analyze, apply, and explain methods for solving problems involving proportions and percents.
M. develop, analyze, and explain arithmetic sequences.
N. understand and apply the standard algebraic order of operations.

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

7-8 Overview

The wide availability of computing and calculating technology demands that we significantly reconceive the role of computation and numerical operations in our seventh and eighth grade mathematics programs. Traditionally, tremendous amounts of time were spent at these levels helping students to finish off their development of complex pencil-and-paper procedures for the four basic operations with whole numbers, fractions, and decimals. Now, the societal reality is that adults needing to perform those calculations quickly and accurately have electronic tools that are both more accurate and more efficient than the paper-and-paper procedures. At the same time, though, the new technology has presented us with a situation where some numerical operations, skills, and concepts are much more important than they used to be. Estimation, mental computation, and understanding the meanings of the standard arithmetic operations all play a more significant role than ever in the everyday life of a mathematically literate adult.

The major shift in the curriculum that will take place at these grade levels, therefore, is one away from drill and practice of pencil-and-paper symbolic procedures and toward real-world applications of operations, wise choices of appropriate computational strategies, and integration of the numerical operations with other components of the mathematics curriculum.

Seventh and eighth graders are relatively comfortable with the unit shift discussed in the Grades 5-6 Numerical Operations Overview. Operations on fractions and decimals, as well as whole numbers, should be relatively well developed by this point and the focus switches to a more holistic look at operations. Numerical Operations becomes less a specific object of study and more a process, a set of tools for problem setting. It is critical that teachers spend less time on focused work in this area so that the other areas of the Standards-based curriculum receive adequate attention.

One important set of related topics that do receive some significant attention here, though, is ratio, proportion, and percent. Seventh and eighth graders are cognitively ready for a serious study of these topics and to begin to incorporate proportional reasoning into their set of problem solving tools. Work in this area should start out informally, progressing to the student formulation of procedures that make proportions and percents the powerful tools they are.

Another two topics that receive greater attention here, even though they have been informally introduced earlier, are integer operations and powers and roots. Both of these types of operations further expand the students knowledge of the types of numbers we use and the ways in which we use them.

Estimation, mental math, and technology use begin to mature in seventh and eighth grades as students use these strategies in much the same way that they will as adults. If earlier instruction in these skills has been successful, students will be able to make appropriate choices about which computational strategies to use in given situations and will feel confident in using any of these in addition to pencil-and-paper. Students need to continue to develop the alternatives to pencil-and-paper as they continue to learn more operations on other types of numbers, but the work here is primarily on the continuing use of all of the strategies in rich real-world problem solving settings.

The topics that should comprise the numerical operations focus of the seventh and eighth grade mathematics program are:

rational number operations
integer operations
powers and roots
proportion and percent

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

7-8 Expectations and Activities

The expectations for these grade levels appear below in boldface type. Each expectation is followed by activities which illustrate how the expectation can be addressed in the classroom.

Building upon K-6 expectations, experiences in grades 7-8 will be such that all students:

H. select and use an appropriate method for computing from among mental math, estimation, pencil-and-paper, and calculator methods and check the reasonableness of results

I. extend their understanding and use of arithmetic operations to fractions, decimals, integers, and rational numbers.
J. extend their basic understanding of basic arithmetic operations on whole numbers to include powers and roots.
K. develop, analyze, apply, and explain procedures for computation and estimation with whole numbers, fractions, decimals, integers, and rational numbers.
L. develop, analyze, apply, and explain methods for solving problems involving proportions and percents.
M. develop, analyze, and explain arithmetic sequences.
N. understand and apply the standard algebraic order of operations.

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

9-12 Overview

In ninth through twelfth grades, estimation, mental computation, and appropriate calculator and computer use become the focus of this standard. What is different about this standard at this level when compared to the traditional curriculum is its mere presence. In the traditional academic mathematics curriculum, work on numerical operations was basically finished by eighth grade and focus then shifted exclusively to the more abstract work in algebra and geometry. But, in the highly technological and data-driven world in which our students will live and work, strong skills in numerical operations have perhaps even more importance than they once did. By giving our older students a variety of approaches and strategies for the computation that they encounter in everyday life, approaches with which they can confidently approach numerical problems, we prepare them for their future.

The major work in this area, then, that will take place in the high school grades, is continued opportunity for real-world applications of operations, wise choices of appropriate computational strategies, and integration of the numerical operations with other components of the mathematics curriculum.

The only new topics to be introduced in this standard for these grade levels are work with factorials and matrices as useful tools to be used in problem solving situations.

Estimation, mental math, and technology use should fully mature in the high school years as students use these strategies in much the same way that they will as adults. If earlier instruction in these skills has been successful, students will be able to make appropriate choices about which computational strategies to use in given situations and will feel confident in using any of these in addition to pencil-and-paper. Students need to continue to develop the alternatives to pencil-and-paper as they learn more operations on other types of numbers, but the work here is almost exclusively on the continuing use of all of the strategies in rich, real-world, problem solving settings.

The topics that should comprise the numerical operations focus of the ninth through twelfth grade mathematics program are:

operations on real numbers
translation of arithmetic skills to algebraic operations
operations with factorials, exponents, and matrices

STANDARD 11: NUMERICAL OPERATIONS

All students will develop their understanding of numerical operations through experiences which enable them to construct, explain, select, and apply various methods of computation including mental math, estimation, and the use of calculators, with a reduced role for pencil-and-paper techniques.

9-12 Expectations and Activities

The expectations for these grade levels appear below in boldface type. Each expectation is followed by activities which illustrate how the expectation can be addressed in the classroom.

Building upon K-8 expectations, experiences in grades 9-12 will be such that all students:

O. select and use an appropriate method for computing from among mental math, estimation, pencil-and-paper, and calculator methods and check the reasonableness of results.

P. extend their understanding and use of operations to real numbers and algebraic procedures.
Q. develop, analyze, apply, and explain methods for solving problems involving factorials, exponents, and matrices.

New Jersey Mathematics Curriculum Framework - Preliminary Version (January 1995)
© Copyright 1995 New Jersey Mathematics Coalition